Rev. Sara McManus
Senior Pastor

As an avid Christ-follower, I have been searching to understand the mystery that is God my whole life. I've found that a life in Christ is a life spent outside oneself, looking at the world around me and seeing where I can help. Here at First Church we are committed to Christ’s call in each of our lives and to connect to God and community. There’s nothing better about a life of Christ than serving God together!

My husband Kyle and I have two great children and two chaos-dogs. Growing up and finding a call to ministry in Yankton, I've learned the importance of God's path in my life. I have served churches and ministries in Iowa, Tennesee, North and South Dakota. It is a joy to do God's work here in Watertown.
more about Pastor Sara
Rev. Kim Hastings
Associate Pastor

Preaching is one of my favorite things - the entire process from conceptualizing a sermon series, to planning and research, praying, writing, and relaying the message - all of these pieces fill my cup. I have a love for children and youth being in the church. Not just attending worship - but learning to be a valued member and involved in worship experiences, as well as being taught spiritual habits and our beliefs. Helping people learn to ask questions, dig deeper, and grow in their spiritual maturity is another of my strengths.

I love to read, bake, try new recipes and spend time with people. Travelling is enjoyable - mostly to go see family! My favorite way to spend time alone is outside during a summer morning with a slight wind, a fuzzy blanket, a cup of warm coffee and a good book. My favorite way to spend time with family is fishing or playing at a park.
more about Pastor Hastings
Pastor Amy Atkins
Pastor

I believe in building authentic connection—connection with God, with others, and within ourselves. I believe that a community of people can strive toward this goal when they value that every individual is seen, known, and encouraged to discover the unique gifts God has placed within them. My heart is to walk alongside others in this journey, creating spaces where people are empowered to grow spiritually, emotionally, and practically.

Through teaching, discipleship, and collaborative ministry, I am committed to helping individuals uncover their God-given potential and develop the skills needed to serve with confidence and compassion. Whether through worship, mentoring, service, spiritual practice or leadership development, I seek to build a culture of intentional growth and grace-filled accountability. My hope is to see the body of Christ equipped, unified, and mobilized to impact the world with love and purpose.
more about Pastor Amy
Pearl Geffre
Office Manager

Hello, I’ve had the privilege of being the Office Manager here at First Church since 2012.  My job is never dull as there is always something new and interesting that needs to be done or questions that need to be answered.  And, if I don’t know the answer, I’m happy to go on a quest till I find it for you.

My husband, Marty and I have 2 wonderful kids and 3 awesome grandchildren. They all keep us hopping and on the go with school and sports activities and family game nights. When I’m not hanging with the kiddos I love to read, quilt or paint. But my favorite past time is when we go out to the Black Hills and can hike in the beauty of God’s creation!
more about Pearl
Dean Gorseth
Graphic and Media Designer

Hello, my name is Dean Gorseth. I am the Graphic and Media Designer for First United Methodist Church. I am responsible for keeping the church website up to date, as well as creating engaging graphics.  I enjoy using graphics and media to share ideas and teach lessons about Christ. I am familiar with working with churches since I have worked similar positions in the past.

In my free-time I like playing video games, taking walks, and listening to music. I also work on drawing and digital art projects to keep my skills sharp.
more about Dean
Rev. Elmer Brinkman
On Call Pastor
Blair Titze
Music Director, Choir Director, Organist
Lesa Dahl
Organist
Lori Jurgens
Children's Ministry Coordinator

Hi, I’m Lori Jurgens. I am the Director of Children’s Ministries for Wednesday Nights. I started this position on March 1, 2023. I am job sharing this position with Sandy Middleton.  Spending time with the kids on Wednesday nights is a true blessing. We are growing together in Christ. Seeing the energy and love and excitement that these kids have for Jesus is so rewarding. 

I have 3 wonderful children- Gavin, Grace and Gabe who have kept me busy running to all of their activities. I love to read, spend time with my family and friends, boating and puzzles. I also like to travel and my bucket list is to get to all 50 states and to tour Europe. I grew up in a small country church by Castlewood- Bemis Christian Reformed Church where I participated in youth group and enjoyed the friendships I made there and also having my parents as youth leaders. After graduation I moved to Sioux Falls and attended Peace Lutheran Church where I was part of the mommy and me group after I had kids. I have helped out in the past with Wednesday nights at FirstChurch and really enjoyed it so when I felt God calling me to do more I said yes and here I am.
more about Lori
Bobbie Jenner
Co-Children's Ministery Coordinator

Hello, I am honored and privileged to serve as the Co-Children Ministery Coordinator. As a Children Ministery Coordinator I embrace the responsibility to care, protect and lead First Church Children connecting them to God and helping them build their belief while sharing God’s love, grace and words.

My husband Doug, and I live in Henry with our three children (Denver, Tieson and Izrial). We have been blessed to be part of First Church since our wedding in 2005. During our free time, we enjoy the great outdoors, whether we are fishing, camping, in the garden or sitting by the fire. Over the years I have been blessed to lead and support children’s learning in several capacities including as the nursery coordinator, an elementary teacher, special education teacher, First Kids volunteer, youth group volunteer and a specialist who provided therapy for children with autism. I am blessed to continue to support and lead children alongside Lori in their journey of discovering and building their faith.
more about Bobbie
Beth Schutt
Custodian
Plan A Visit
Giving
Groups
Volunteer
Events
Subscribe
Prayer Requests